How Much Does a Wolf Cost?

Grey Wolf in Yellowstone in Spring

The truck’s plates say it all: “4WOLVES.” Inside are an Iowa couple who return to the Yellowstone country year after year to be campground hosts in the nation’s first national park. They return for the stunning scenery, for the wide open country that is the Lamar Valley, for herds of elk, for shaggy bison and for wolves.

Today’s Yellowstone is a different place than 1995’s Yellowstone. Biologists and ecologists can see it on the ground. Outdoor educators see it in their businesses. And visitors see it on the roads.

Travel the road from Cooke City into the Lamar Valley and you’ll see it too. At pullouts all up and down the valley will be dozens of people standing, pointing, quietly observing. They are there for Yellowstone’s wolves.

Jim Halfpenny is an outdoor educator who specializes in large carnivores. He lives in Gardiner, Montana, a town on the northern edge of the park and from there, he runs classes in wolf ecology. In 1995, he taught one class. Since that time, he has seen the wolf education business spring to life.

“There were fifty-four classes on wolves taught in the first half of 2000 from eleven different organizations. From an educational standpoint, this has just been monstrous in the way it has developed,” said Halfpenny.

Wolves Mean Less Elk for Hunters and Hunting Outfitters

Economically, the story has been extremely bright. In 1992, before wolves were reintroduced into the park, a University of Montana economist named John Duffield co-authored a study entitled “The Economics of Wolf Recovery in Yellowstone National Park.” That study predicted a loss to the hunter/outfitter business on the high end of about $500,000 per year. This would be a direct loss to hunting outfitters due to the fact that a declining elk population due to wolves would mean less elk to hunt, which would mean less clients. On the flip side, the benefits to wolf recovery in terms of tourism dollars, educators, and outfitters who specialized in wildlife observation, not hunting, were predicted in the $7-10 million annual range, a gain many times greater than the loss.

A follow-up study to check the accuracy of the predictions is about a year away from publication, but the preliminary numbers look very similar, said Duffield. People want to see wolves, and they come from all over the world to do so. And they bring money.

For a motel owner who struggles during the dreaded “shoulder-season”-those months between the peak tourist seasons-wolves have been extremely good news. Three years ago, Gerlie Weinstein left her life in New Orleans as an English teacher to come to Cooke City to run a business and watch wildlife. Today, she owns the Alpine Motel in Cooke City.

“My business has increased yearly, and increased from the business that the former owners did,” said Weinstein. “I came here because I watch wildlife and that’s what a lot of my clients do.”

The months of April, October, and November can be hard times for motel owners, but with the addition of wolves into the park, businesses like the Alpine Motel don’t need to close up shop during these times.

“We had our best November and best October ever last fall, that would be people coming to see the wildlife,” she said. “They are coming for the wolves and they are coming for the bears.”

What’s more, the potential is just barely being tapped, according to some observers.

“Over time, I think this is really going to be considered as a world class opportunity for people to see wolves in the wild,” said Rick McIntyre, who works for the National Park Service to provide help educate wolf watchers. In terms of the economic impact, there’s just tremendous potential for local business people. To me that’s just a tremendously positive potential, having the wolves here.”

Halfpenny has made an attempt to quantify and compare the economic returns of wolf watching to elk hunting.

Yellowstone-Wildlife-Elk-9

What’s Brings in More Money – Wolf Watching or Elk Hunting?

“One exercise that I do in my wolf classes is I put up a blackboard and I have the people go through and make some sort of evaluation of what wolf watching brings into the northern Yellowstone ecosystem in dollars and what hunting brings,” said Halfpenny. “There’s a lot of assumptions in such an exercise, but the bottom line is in the northern (Yellowstone) ecosystem, wolf watching brings in four times what hunting is bringing in.

“We have counted 100,000 visitors as of June of last year that have been out and watched wolves and then you make assumptions about what they spend in the filling station, the restaurants, etcetera, and what the hunters spend,” said Halfpenny. “You know Montana’s own statistics show the average late-hunt hunter spends $39 a day up here.”

Halfpenny figures that wolf watchers spend about $160 per day in the area. And there’s tremendous potential for growth.

“It’s obvious that wolves are one of the most charismatic animals in the world and there’s no end to how many people would like to see a wolf in the wild, so Yellowstone is one of the most unique opportunities in the world where an average person can and does have a real excellent chance of having that experience,” said McIntyre.

Comment Feed

44 Responses

  1. Non Resident elk hunters spend $130+- a day. Assuming they purchase a $912.00 combination deer/elk tag. $39 a day is pretty cheap livin’, considering you have a hard time finding a hotel for that, or a tank of gas, or a box of ammo, or a new pair of pants, or a hunting knife, or a bar tab.
    If one were to live off of $39 a day, that would mean you only spend $14,040.00 annually, elk huntin’ is cheap! I live in Montana, hunt in Montana, and I am positive I spend at least $50 a hunting day, not counting license, tags, fees.
    Ask a non resident hunter how much his trip to Montana cost him. Ask him how long he saved up for it.
    Ask him if he would like to see wolves.
    If MT FWP were to sell all 17,000 non-resident combination tag in the quota(which this year they wont)the gross income would be $15,504,000.00 which is where at least some of the money comes from for wolf management programs.
    Wolf watchers/park tourists,100,000 of them,spend $160 a day, which is $16,000,000.00. How much of that revenue goes to the managing of wolves? Just the park fees? Any of it? Has tourism increased since the reintroduction of wolves? If so, has the increase in revenue surpassed the price of managing the wolf population? Does that revenue pay restitution for the stock depredation? Helicopter rental for government employees to kill problem wolves? Does it even cover the cost of the initial reintroduction?
    The money for wolf management is the responsibility of entities outside of the park, MT FWP, Department of Agriculture(government trappers), ID F&G, WY G&F, because that’s where they are a problem. Just cant seem to keep the wolves in the park! There is no elk hunting in the park, or hunting at all, so no, hunters dont spend alot of time or money in the park. The above article is candy coated. A wolf fluff piece. A tourism brochure article.

    I am not against wolves, I am against people that claim wolves are good for the economy. I am against experts lying to the public. I am against seemingly intelligent people that refuse to admit they are wrong. I am against people hiding behind a “noble cause” to cash in on taxpayers money. I am against fraud, waste, and abuse of government funds, a.k.a. taxpayers money.

    If you want to see wolves, skip the park and the crowds. Go to the Bighole, there are more wolves there anyway.

    Dave HottellOctober 19, 2011 @ 8:30 am
  2. Hi Dave, I’m a wolf watcher/lover who also appreciates decisions being based upon fact rather than myth. I don’t believe current wolf hunting/management decisions are based upon fact, but rather fear and hate. Can hunters and wolf lovers talk to each other? I certainly hope so. Can they find common ground – at least some? I hope so. Let’s start. Thanks, Monica

  3. Dave, if you’re against abuse of government funds, then I’m sure you are opposed to the federal agency Wildlife Services, which spends millions of taxpayer dollars every year to kill numerous wild species on behalf of ranchers, farmers, etc. This is one of the most wasteful govt. agencies in existence, and it needs to be defunded NOW.

    Joby 79May 9, 2012 @ 7:54 am
  4. Dave has a point people, when are you gullible people going to wake up and smell the coffee? I have it brewing right now, Peet’s Coffee extra strong for those who are drinking far too much chamomile tea! Now we could get you some ginko biloba tea. What is disturbing though are the countless shows about hunters shooting animals for sport. Now that is wrong and when I asked the Native Americans their response was ” you cannot trust white people”!! I have to agree and I am white too. People who want a nice trophy on their wall for a conversation piece, sorry but again that is wrong. These national parks are great that they offer the masses a wonderful opportunity to see animals in their natural environment so why not invite criminals to come visit us in our homes? Do any of you think these animals want to see humans? No! What do you think they are thinking about seeing millions of idiots in the park? “Get out”!! How many people, in the park, ride bikes? Drive electric vehicles? Drive hybrids? Actually get out of their cars and walk more than 1/4 of a mile? I bet the percentage is around 2-5% with is pretty lame people. Those huge motor homes, trucks, tour buses pollute in such an awful way then the people in them are either so over weight and just want some pictures to show their family members “hey we went to Yellowstone”. I interviewed many when I was there this winter and asked them where are their favorite hikes? “hikes”? Are you kidding was their response. Why hike when you can drive? Like I said, idiots in a beautiful park surrounded by stunning scenery and I can imagine a Bison thinking “that’s it stupid human come a little close so I can charrrrrrrrrrrrrrge” What I am doing right now is posting videos of complacency in National Parks.

  5. Move to Montana where there is an abundance of wolves, and i am sure you will change your view. Hunting wolves in any National park is against the Law. Outside of National Parks, Hunting thins out wolf packs and provides a management tool for wildlife biologists to ensure wolf numbers remain healthy and manageable. Too many wolves stresses the Elk and Deer populations. Wolf hunting ensures the Elk and Deer populations remain healthy and not over hunted by too many wolves in the ecosystem. Without hunting the winter kill numbers of wolves would be high. If there is not enough food available to sustain the number of wolves, wolves would die of starvation or freeze to death. And what about the sheep and cattle ranchers who have already suffered livestock losses due to wolves? They deserve to be compensated. There are plenty of wolves in Montana too take pictures of. The wolf is native to Montana and the west, it belongs here, however to let the wolf population numbers run wild and be against the hunting of wolves is just asinine. I think anyone who lives where there are no wolf populations really should just not have an opinion until they are able to form an opinion based on real experience.

  6. I have no real experience in many things, but that doesn’t preclude me from understanding the difference between fact and rhetoric. Shooing wolves wantonly, calling them the ‘Saddam Hussein” of the animal world, setting traps such as barbaric snares, poisoning their food with compounds that cause excruciating suffering, having shoot on sight policies such as those proposed in the Wyoming management plan, that destroy non-problem wolves with long range rifles, just about anywhere in the state and throughout most of the year, this is not science, and it is not acceptable, and you don’t have to have experience with wolves to know that.

    I will tell you this, your state will not see my money for tourism with these policies and I will do everything I can to make sure that everyone I know does the same.

    Michelle

  7. Why do people insist on making wolves out to be the big bad animal? I agree that they do not need to overpopulate themselves, but shoot on sight is simply unacceptable. There are more humane ways to thin the population than butchering them. How about psay/neutering, or injections to make them sterile?? Sounds better than just blowing out their brains beacuse they are wolves. God put them here for a reason and until God decides to destroy them..Man has no right to!!!!! Please stop this waste of a beautiful animal who just wants to survive in this over populated uncaring selfish world.

  8. An escrow officer can help to explain a contract to both the
    buyer and the seller. 00 a month during the construction of
    the “G” Street Undercrossing Project. Ghaziabad is located
    near Delhi, capital of India and a part of NCR.
    No money down to make a real estate purchase is possible according to real estate experts.
    We shall take their technical assistance and work with
    Indian technology companies to create these attractions at
    modest Indian prices. Activists came from as far away as Santa Barbara by train, and carpooled from San Francisco,
    Chico, Grass Valley, and Monterey Bay. Toppings, stuffing and all the fixings will be our main focus.
    Customers may enter into long-term pricing contracts for wind to reduce the risk of future pricing
    changes, thereby ensuring more stable returns for projects
    at the development stage. Appropriating $500,000 in Neighborhood Stabilization Program property resale funds to account 059-1352-657.
    For investors to compare apples to apples, you need an alternative investment is basically as simple as any other investment option.

  9. Hey there just wanted to give you a quick heads up.
    Thhe text in your article seem to be running off tthe screen in Opera.
    I’m not sure if this is a formatting issue or something too doo with web browser compatibility but I thhought
    I’d post to let you know. The layout look great though!

    Hope you get the problem solved soon. Cheers

  10. Hello to every , because I am really eager of rsading this
    blog’s post to bbe updated daily. It includes nijce information.

  11. Just not as much as it may have, you know, three seasons ago.
    In my humble opinion, Diddy out did the swagga of the original Swagga Like Us song.

    , real name Mathangi Arulpragasam, announced on her My –
    Space blog on Saturday (February 14) that her baby born Feb.

  12. It’s in fact very complex in this busy life to listen news on Television,
    so I simply uuse world wide web for that purpose, and obtain the hottest news.

  13. Ecellent way of telling, aand pleasant post to obtain data aboout
    my presentation subject, which i am going to convey in college.

  14. I feel that is one of the so much significant info for me.
    And i’m satisfied studying your article. However want to remark on few normal things, The website
    taste is wonderful, the articles is really great : D.

    Just right activity, cheers

  15. I have been surfing online more than 4 hours today, yet I never found any interesting article
    like yours. It’s pretty worth enough for me.
    In my view, if all webmasters and bloggers made good content as you did, the internet will be a lot more useful than ever
    before.

  16. I visited multiple blogs but the audio feature for audio songs
    preent at this website is really fabulous.

  17. This website was… how do you say it? Relevant!!
    Finally I’ve found something which helped me.
    Appreciate it!

  18. Hi to all, because I am in fact keen of reading this webpage’s post to
    be updated on a regular basis. It consists of nice information.

  19. What’s up to all, how is the whole thing, I think every one is
    getting more from this website, and your views are good for new viewers.

  20. Amazing blog! Do you have any tips and hints for aspiring writers?

    I’m hoping tto start my own blog soon bbut I’m a little lost on everything.

    Would yoou suggest sstarting with a free platform like WordPress or go for
    a paid option? There are so many options out there that I’m completely confused ..
    Any recommendations? Cheers!

  21. That’s because the 6-year-old from Virginia is the youngest person ever to qualify
    for the competition. We don’t mean it when we say that people check their brains
    with their baggage. The Cricut Imagine is the only die
    cut machine from Provo Craft that can not only cut, but also
    print.

  22. whoah this blog is magnificent i really like studying your posts.
    Keep up the great work! Youu already know, lots
    of persons are searching round for this info,
    you can elp them greatly.

  23. Pretty component to content. I just stumbled upon your web site and
    inn accession capital to claim that I get actually loved account your
    blog posts. Anyway I’ll be subscribing in your feeds orr even I success
    you get right oof entry to consistgently quickly.

  24. Aw, this was a really nice post. Taking a few minutes and actual effort to produce a really
    good article… but what can I say… I procrastinate a lot and don’t manage to get anything done.

  25. It is important to purchase your equipment off a legitimate
    supplier who offers a warranty or guarantee. The process begins with the application of a p –
    H-balancing spray to prevent the dreaded orange look.
    Though Taser products might not be best for everyone to use, it can be perfect to have if there is an immediate threat
    to your life and you are not comfortable with carrying a gun. The DHA contained in the tanning
    mixture is Food and Drugs Association approved. As you’re applying fake tan it is important to
    not miss any spots. In order to avoid such sunless
    tanning accidents, you must first understand the causes
    responsible for turning your skin orange. Fake tan is nothing but
    a cream, lotion or a spray containing tan color which should be applied
    all over your body to get those sensuous
    tanned looks. Allow the oil to soak into the body for at least 20 minutes and then wash it and the unsightly blotches away.
    If you are one of those people that would love to have a year round, sexy, deep tan, but do not want the harmful effects that the
    sun’s rays or a tanning bed can do to you, and then sunless tanning is for you.
    You need to evaluate both, before going ahead with your option.

  26. It’s really a cool and helpful piece of information. I am satisfied that you simply shared
    this useful info with us. Please stay us informed like this.
    Thank you for sharing.

  27. Advanced Plastic Surgery is here to celebrate beauty with its state of the art facilities and innovative services such as
    dermabrasion, BOTOX Cosmetic, body surgeries, and the latest
    Vi – Peel. Calvert states, it requires a great deal of planning
    and preparation, as well as a lengthy recovery time (a three to five week hospital stay, with about
    six weeks of home rest prior to returning to work).
    With an type of plastic surgery, there will be a recovery process.

  28. At this time it seems like BlogEngine is the top blogging platform available
    right now. (from what I’ve read) Is that what you’re using on your
    blog?

  29. Good information. Lucky me I recently found your website by
    chance (stumbleupon). I’ve bookmarked it for later!

  30. The more time you spend researching the costs of your venture,
    the higher the profits you will see. Your investing needs to provide a living -and a lifestyle.

    You can do some things that may make you some money in the
    mean time. Real estate Internet marketing has launched in a big way with
    Web 2. Do it slowly with purpose and really enjoy how it
    feels. In fact, the market for real estate online investing could be better.
    With statehood, properties values in the following small island
    country will skyrocket. The probate market is pretty healthy no
    matter what the economy is doing, so it offers some stability that you can’t find in other types of real estate investing.
    I finally have some say in what happens regarding my professional life.

    Cash transactions, in this market, means private investors.

  31. Prety section of content. I just stumbled uon yor blog and
    in accession capital to say that I acquire actually loved account your weblog posts.
    Anny way I’ll be subscribing on your augment or even I success you get rigyht of entry to consistently quickly.

  32. Hey there, I think your blog might be having browser compatibility
    issues. When I look at your website in Ie, it
    looks fine but when opening in Internet Explorer, it has some overlapping.
    I just wanjted to give you a quick heads up!
    Other then that, excellent blog!

  33. This web site does not display properly on my android – you may want to try and repair that

  34. Quite a few treatment centers impose as per the time required each meeting.
    Blow drying can damage hair as can vigorous towel drying as when the hair is wet it is more elastic and vulnerable to breakage.
    Speaking of ball game, do you know that you can advertise using your bald head.

  35. I’m gone to convey my little brother, that he should also pay a quick visit this blog on regular basis to get updated from latest
    reports.

  36. Many if not all the styles are fashionable, trendy and hip.
    You are only recommended to use this type of
    dress as long as your body allows it. Many people are interested in knowing these and thus, if one is looking to start a fashion website,
    all they have to do is to include this aspect to their portal along with
    pictures as well.

  37. They use artwork and fonts that are available on cartridges.
    If your paper airplane doesn’t go very far or very fast, just keep
    practicing until it does. You have just constructed a very basic paper airplane.

  38. In fact, wereit not too late already, and perhaps always by nature had been, if only dueto the freely-chosen as
    well as popularly-tolerated if notenthusiastically-supported
    incorrigibility of those with all the real,pseudo-individually, thus no less pseudo-collectively decision-making power,but
    who will undoubtedly never listen, at least not on time; then the bestof all possible advice,
    at this point, at least while, as Gore puts it,”gliding through a skid,”
    might have been provided, not by the real – Superman, but
    rather from Lois and Clark; for, in that version, Supermansimply turns off the engine.
    Most companies provide “tax equalization,” which means
    that they’ll make sure that your after-tax income – no
    matter what – is equal to what it would have been if you’d stayed stateside.
    When one takes a clearly sober, rationally well-balanced view here, from the perspective of God’s own attitude, all it actually amounts to is a fervent wish that the one forgiven will ultimately succeed at finding his way,
    seeing the light, and being granted mercy.

  39. Heya just wanted to give you a quick heads up and let you know
    a few of the pictures aren’t loading correctly.
    I’m not sure why but I think its a linking issue. I’ve tried it in two different internet browsers and both show the same results.

  40. It’s tough, but I riad marrakech morocco blue eyes did steal from
    this the notion that positrons were electrons going backwards in time.

    This would lower truck fleet fuel costs by more
    than 50% over the next year but refused to reopen the border, 30 of them passed
    the fence and were expelled to Morocco according local authorities.

  41. Thwnks for the auspicious writeup. It in truth was ojce a amusement
    accout it. Glance advanced to more delivered ageeable from
    you! By the way, how could we be iin contact?

  42. Many of the Homeopathic h – CG solutions contain no h – CG at all.
    The EPT pregnancy test will normally have a test display window which will not only show the outcome of the test but also whether or not the test is
    being undertaken in accordance with the manufacturer. When you are doing
    caloric cycling you will have burn days and feed days.

  43. Hi there, You have done an incredible job. I will certainly
    digg it and personally suggest to my friends.
    I am confident they’ll be benefited from this web site.



Some HTML is OK

or, reply to this post via trackback.

Continuing the Discussion